News and Blog

In a bid to spur the construction of ADUs and combat San Diego County’s housing crisis, including an acute shortage of affordable housing, the San Diego County Board of Supervisors voted in January to adopt a five-year trial program to waive fees for ADUs. In the wake of the City of San Diego’s fee waiver in July 2018, this program is expected to reduce construction costs for ADUs by approximately $14,000.

“This is a really big deal,” said Board of Supervisors Chairwoman Dianne Jacob. Together with efforts at the state level to limit regulations on ADU development, the fee waiver creates an economic motivation for developing ADUs. “We talk a lot about housing, the need for housing, and the need for affordable housing. This is the easiest and quickest way to get there,” remarked Board Chairwoman Jacob.

In recent years, rents in the region have increased substantially and the vacancy rate has dropped to 3.3%, exacerbating housing pressures. Due at least in part to costly development impact fees (for, e.g., electrical hookups, road construction, sewer connections, and public school support), ADU construction in San Diego and its environs has lagged despite the adoption of Senate Bill 1069, which was intended to encourage such projects. Given these facts, advocates for affordable housing and others are anxious for this trial program, for which San Diego County is providing $11 million to offset lost fee revenues, to promote the building of ADUs.

Now that state law requires local governments to pare back procedural and design restrictions against the development of accessory dwelling units (“ADUs”) in California , there has been a marked increase in the number of ADU projects across the state. In Los Angeles, for example, nearly 8,000 property owners submitted ADU plans in September 2017. Despite these loosened limitations, however, it appears that many ADU applicants are running into a new hitch; namely, state regulations that mandate that new structures be built between 4’-6’ of horizontal clearance away from the aerial path of overhead power lines, in order to help prevent those power lines from falling onto the structure in the event of a break in the lines.

These power line clearance requirements have been established by the State of California in order to protect public safety and the interests of the utility companies that own the power lines. “We have to maintain these clearances for the safety of the public and for our workers,” says Dan Barnes, director of power transmission and distribution for the City of Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, because if “someone goes out and touches [a downed] line, they could be severely injured or killed.” According to the City of Los Angeles Department of City Planning, these power line clearance requirements affect “potentially one in every five to six permit applications” in Los Angeles.

In Silicon Valley, where the housing shortage has reached acute levels and efforts to address this crisis have taken on many forms, the City of Palo Alto has expected and prepared for an upswing in ADU applications. Like Los Angeles but unlike most cities, however, Palo Alto operates its own electric utility and is responsible for enforcing power line clearances and other state-mandated safety rules. As in Los Angeles, this fact poses a challenge for ADU development in Palo Alto.

In another similarity to Los Angeles, many neighborhoods in Palo Alto are served by utility lines that run across the rear of residential properties, including high-voltage transmission lines that require significantly more than the standard 4’-6’ clearances. According to a written statement issued by the City of Palo Alto Utilities, the increased clearance areas “needed for the higher voltage transmission lines would be to accommodate the larger footprint of the towers suspending the lines. These are larger than the single wooden poles found more commonly running through neighborhoods.” The total clearance needed to accommodate the footprint of such power lines is potentially larger than the typical residential property.

Because these clearance requirements are established under state law, municipal governments such as those in Los Angeles and Palo Alto seeking to encourage the development of ADUs lack the authority to waive these regulations. Due to this fact, any effort to permit these power line clearance mandates to be loosened in order to promote ADUs would require a change in state law to carry out this intent. Such legislation introduced in the last session of the California legislature, but did not pass .

In the meantime, the best advice for those people who are interested in developing an ADU, either with new construction or by converting an unused outbuilding or garage, is to pay close attention to the physical details of your property relative to power lines. Visual inspections can be useful for identifying potential clearance issues, but to be certain, it is necessary to review a survey of your property and confirm with your local building department and utility provider whether there are power line clearance requirements for your property.

With the recent explosion of interest in “tiny homes” and accessory dwelling units (ADUs) as potential solutions to the affordable housing shortage in many urban centers, a number of people are wondering which way to turn to obtain useful information about this new trend in housing. One of the most helpful resources available today is Backdoor Revolution: The Definitive Guide to ADU Development, written by Kol Peterson, a leader in the tiny house movement.

This book is a thorough resource for those who may be considering designing, building and possibly living in or offering for rent a “tiny house,” or ADU. Written by a veteran of ADU projects, it recaps the reasons for the growth in the ADU market, and offers specific advice and pointers on these projects.

The first half of book serves as an in-depth, detailed guide to the process of designing and building an ADU. Topics covered include costs, financing, permitting, ADU design, rental models, and step-by-step development guidance. It has been written primarily for homeowners who want to develop ADUs on their properties.

The second half of the book dives into larger issues that have kept ADUs from taking off in most U.S. cities until now. With case studies and a synthesis of research regarding ADUs, Backdoor Revolution can provide city planners and ADU advocates many tools to use to promote the development of more ADUs in their communities.